The Trouble with Instruments: The Need for Pretreatment Balance in Shock-Based Instrumental Variable Designs

Vladimir Atanasov
Vladimir Atanasov
[email protected]
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1893-6187
Raymond A. Mason School of Business, William and Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia 23187;
Search for more papers by this author
,
Bernard Black
Corresponding Author
Bernard Black
[email protected]
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-6499-0600
Northwestern University, Pritzker School of Law and Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois 60611
Search for more papers by this author

Raymond A. Mason School of Business, William and Mary, Williamsburg, Virginia 23187;

Corresponding Author

Bernard Black

Northwestern University, Pritzker School of Law and Kellogg School of Management, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois 60611

Search for more papers by this author

Published Online:6 Jul 2020https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2019.3510

Supplemental Material

mnsc.2019.3510.sm1.pdf

Cited by
- Does financial innovation lead to technological innovation? Evidence from foreign exchange derivatives
  Research Policy, Vol. 55, No. 7
- Asymmetric cost behavior and non-financial firms’ risky financial investments
  Journal of Banking & Finance, Vol. 187
- Creditor rights, bank monitoring, and corporate risk-taking: evidence from creditor rights reform
  27 April 2025 | Applied Economics, Vol. 58, No. 23
- SEC scrutiny and corporate risk-taking
  Journal of Accounting and Economics, Vol. 81, No. 3
- Beyond computation: How National Supercomputing Centers facilitate new business entry
  Journal of Business Venturing, Vol. 41, No. 3
- When rivals collaborate: the effect of resource constraints on intergovernmental collaboration
  26 August 2025 | Journal of Chinese Governance, Vol. 11, No. 2
- Access to Debt and the Provision of Trade Credit
  Matthew Billett,
  Kayla Freeman,
  Janet Gao
  13 August 2025 | Management Science, Vol. 72, No. 4
- Liquidity Constraints and Auditor Responses to Repo Transactions
  10 December 2025 | Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 53, No. 2
- Forced corporate social responsibility and incentive to manage earnings: evidence from a quasi-natural experiment
  17 March 2025 | Applied Economics, Vol. 58, No. 13
- Mandatory CSR spending and firm risk: New evidence from regulatory intervention in India
  Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 98
- Corporate social responsibility and debt maturity structure: evidence from a quasi-natural experiment
  3 February 2026 | Meditari Accountancy Research, Vol. 34, No. 1
- The Cost of Related Party Transactions and the Intensity of Related Party Transactions: Evidence From Creditor Rights Reform
  19 August 2025 | Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 53, No. 1
- Can finance and accounting supervision inhibit greenwashing? Evidence from a quasi-natural experiment
  13 January 2026 | China Finance Review International, Vol. 53
- 10‐K Readability and Shareholder Proposals on Corporate Governance
  26 May 2025 | Corporate Governance: An International Review, Vol. 34, No. 1
- Redesigning Executive Incentives: The Rising Role of Subjective Performance Measures
  8 December 2025 | The Accounting Review, Vol. 101, No. 1
- Audit fee implications of mandatory CSR
  18 December 2025 | International Journal of Accounting & Information Management, Vol. 32
- Performance of risk-based models in value-based healthcare: Evidence from accountable care organizations
  Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol. 115
- Creditor rights and innovation: evidence from a quasi-natural experiment
  Journal of Contemporary Accounting & Economics, Vol. 21, No. 3
- Impact of enhancing national autonomous innovation demonstration zones on cities’ efficiency in technological innovation
  11 July 2025 | Scientific Reports, Vol. 15, No. 1
- Shocks to CEO Political Alignment and Corporate Social Responsibility: Evidence from the 2008 and 2016 Presidential Elections
  1 February 2025 | The International Journal of Accounting, Vol. 60, No. 04
- Is Stakeholder Orientation Related to Corporate Tax Avoidance? New Evidence
  3 November 2025 | Accounting Horizons, Vol. 39, No. 4
- Analyzing price efficiency using machine learning generated price indices: The case of the Chilean used car market
  Economic Modelling, Vol. 152
- Health Insurance Efficiency: The Impacts of COVID-19, Market Segments, and Operational Strategies
  16 April 2025 | North American Actuarial Journal, Vol. 29, No. 4
- Trust and land Lease: The role of informal institutions in land market in rural China
  Habitat International, Vol. 164
- Going out and bringing in: Impact of digital finance on firms' cross-regional investments
  International Review of Financial Analysis, Vol. 106
- Does Contractionary Monetary Policy Decrease Firm’s R&D Investments? Evidence from India’s Demonetisation
  12 November 2024 | The Indian Economic Journal, Vol. 73, No. 5
- Internal Accounting Hiring and Operational Efficiency: Evidence from the Implementation of ASC 842
  29 July 2025 | The Accounting Review, Vol. 100, No. 5
- Employee Board Representation and Capital Investment
  Qinglu Jin,
  Hui Ma,
  Thomas Schmid,
  Guochang Zhang
  15 November 2024 | Management Science, Vol. 71, No. 8
- State Ownership, Environmental Regulation, and Corporate Green Investment: Evidence from China’s 2015 Environmental Protection Law Changes
  3 December 2024 | Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 200, No. 2
- The Effects of Going Public on Firm Profitability and Strategy
  24 April 2025 | The Review of Financial Studies, Vol. 38, No. 8
- Digital transformation in banking: Curbing procyclical leverage to strengthen financial stability
  International Review of Financial Analysis, Vol. 103
- The impact of automation on firms' reporting quality
  Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 92
- Executive accountability systems and the financial investments of state-owned enterprises in China
  Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, Vol. 91
- Responses of Green Innovation to Carbon Emission Policies in China's Construction Industry
  Resources, Conservation and Recycling, Vol. 219
- Reducing Medical Costs of Health Insurance: The COVID-19 Stress Testing and Portfolio Effects
  19 July 2024 | North American Actuarial Journal, Vol. 29, No. 2
- Dark trading volume and market quality: A natural experiment
  Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 91
- Shifting risk preferences of foreign institutional investors on corporate social responsibility amidst the U.S.-China trade war
  Journal of International Money and Finance, Vol. 154
- Nominal Price (Dis)Illusion: Fractional Shares on Neobroker Trading Platforms
  17 February 2025 | Journal of Behavioral Finance, Vol. 32
- Little emperor CEOs: Firm risk and performance when CEOs grow up without siblings
  Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 90
- What drives firms’ Belt and Road strategy, performance, and CSR?
  29 December 2024 | SN Business & Economics, Vol. 5, No. 1
- Achieving low-carbon production: Impacts of land misallocation and industrial structure in urban China
  Applied Energy, Vol. 378
- Market reaction to EU CRD IV regulation in the banking industry
  Research in International Business and Finance, Vol. 73
- Is Stakeholder Orientation Related to Corporate Tax Avoidance? New Evidence
  1 January 2025 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 74
- The Disruptive Effect of Failed Acquisition Attempts
  1 January 2025 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 117
- Impact of China’s free trade zones on the innovation performance of firms: evidence from a quasi-natural experiment
  2 January 2024 | Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, Vol. 11, No. 1
- Individual Auditor Social Responsibility and Audit Quality: Evidence from China
  4 February 2024 | Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 194, No. 1
- The unswayed voter: How a polarized electorate responds to economic growth
  Electoral Studies, Vol. 90
- Methods for Causal Inference in Marketing
  11 July 2024 | Foundations and Trends® in Marketing, Vol. 18, No. 3-4
- Worldwide board reforms and financial reporting quality
  Research in International Business and Finance, Vol. 69
- Understanding Private Equity Funds: A Guide to Private Equity Research in Accounting
  8 April 2024 | Journal of Financial Reporting, Vol. 9, No. 1
- Strengthening operational creditor rights and trade credit: Evidence from creditor reforms
  Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, Vol. 83
- The semantic complexity of financial disclosures
  1 January 2024 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 13
- Retail Investors and Corporate Governance: Evidence from Zero-Commission Trading
  1 January 2024 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 97
- Pay Transparency and Financial Leverage
  1 January 2024 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 108
- Stock market liberalization and earnings management: Evidence from a quasi‐natural experiment in China
  19 October 2023 | Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol. 40, No. 4
- Does an effective bankruptcy reform increases collateralized borrowing? Evidence from a quasi-natural experiment in India
  8 March 2023 | Journal of Regulatory Economics, Vol. 63, No. 1-2
- Where should the money go? The green effect of governmental guidance when sustainable finance impacts brown firms
  Pacific-Basin Finance Journal, Vol. 78
- The Impact of Officials’ Off-Office Accountability Audit of Natural Resource Assets on Firms’ Green Innovation Strategies: A Quasi-Natural Experiment in China
  1 February 2023 | Sustainability, Vol. 15, No. 3
- Losing our way? A critical examination of path analysis in accounting research
  1 January 2023 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 5
- Asymmetric Cost Behavior and Non-Financial Firms’ Risky Financial Investments
  1 January 2023 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 6
- The Impact of Money in Politics on Labor and Capital: Evidence from Citizens United V. FEC
  1 January 2023 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 105
- An Explanation of Path Analysis and Recommendations for Best Practice
  1 January 2023 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 5
- Cross-Border Regulatory Cooperation and Firm Cross-Listing Decisions
  1 January 2023 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 14
- Nominal Price (Dis)illusion: Fractional Shares on Neobroker Trading Platforms
  1 January 2023 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 30
- Cross-Section of Returns, Predictors Credibility, and Method Issues
  5 January 2023 | Journal of Risk and Financial Management, Vol. 16, No. 1
- Chief executive officer ability and cash holding decision
  1 November 2022 | Review of Accounting and Finance, Vol. 21, No. 5
- Test power properties of within-firm estimators of ownership and board-related explanatory variables with low time variation
  16 July 2022 | Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, Vol. 59, No. 3
- Clogged Intermediation: Were Home Buyers Crowded Out?
  14 December 2021 | Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, Vol. 54, No. 4
- How Does Online Lending Influence Bankruptcy Filings?
  Hongchang Wang,
  Eric M. Overby
  27 May 2021 | Management Science, Vol. 68, No. 5
- Enterprise Intelligent Audit Model by Using Deep Learning Approach
  4 October 2021 | Computational Economics, Vol. 59, No. 4
- Population ageing, labour market rigidity and corporate innovation: Evidence from China
  Research Policy, Vol. 51, No. 2
- Are retail investors really passive? Shareholder activism in the digital age
  30 December 2021 | Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 49, No. 3-4
- The need to validate exogenous shocks: Shareholder derivative litigation, universal demand laws and firm behavior
  Journal of Accounting and Economics, Vol. 73, No. 1
- Mandatory CSR expenditure and stock market liquidity
  Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 72
- The real economic costs of COVID-19: Insights from electricity consumption data in Hunan Province, China
  Energy Economics, Vol. 105
- Does Mandatory CSR Expenditure Regulation Induce Corporate Risk-Taking?
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 102
- The Impact of Money in Politics on Labor and Capital: Evidence from Citizens United v. FEC
  1 January 2022 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 105
- When Values Align: Corporate Philanthropy and Employee Turnover
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 19
- The “butterfly effect” in strategic human capital: Mitigating the endogeneity concern about the relationship between turnover and performance
  18 August 2021 | Strategic Management Journal, Vol. 42, No. 13
- Impacts of the desulfurization price subsidy policy on SO2 reduction: Evidence from China's coal-fired power plants
  Energy Policy, Vol. 157
- Firm opacity and the opportunity cost of cash
  Journal of Corporate Finance, Vol. 68
- The Effect of Board Structure on Firm Disclosure and Behavior: A Case Study of Korea and a Comparison of Research Designs
  25 June 2021 | Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, Vol. 18, No. 2
- Dollar Liquidity, Trade Invoicing, and Real Effects: Evidence from India
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 101
- Noisy Factors
  1 January 2021 | SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 26
- Operational Risk Capital
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 130
- The Need to Validate Exogenous Shocks: Shareholder Derivative Litigation, Universal Demand Laws and Financial Reporting Decisions
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 5
- Did Tax Reform Influence the Prevalence of Nonfinancial Compensation Incentives?
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 90
- Do Seasoned Industry Specialists Provide Higher Audit Quality? A Response
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 70
- CSR Expenditure and Stock Liquidity
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 70
- Do Long-Tenured Boards Provide Stability?
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 18
- Dark Trading Volume and Market Quality: A Natural Experiment
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 1
- How Stable Is Corporate Ownership?
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 26
- Does Financial Innovation Enhance or Inhibit Real Innovation?
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 56
- Does Corporate Governance Affect Earnings Management? Evidence from an Exogenous Shock to Governance in Korea
  SSRN Electronic Journal, Vol. 91

Volume 67, Issue 2

February 2021

Pages 661-1328, iii-iv

Article Information

Supplemental Material

Metrics

Information

Received:January 21, 2018
Accepted:September 03, 2019
Published Online:July 06, 2020

Cite as

Vladimir Atanasov, Bernard Black (2020) The Trouble with Instruments: The Need for Pretreatment Balance in Shock-Based Instrumental Variable Designs. Management Science 67(2):1270-1302.

https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2019.3510

Keywords

PDF download

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

Available Issues

The Trouble with Instruments: The Need for Pretreatment Balance in Shock-Based Instrumental Variable Designs

Supplemental Material

Volume 67, Issue 2

Article Information

Supplemental Material

Metrics

Information

Cite as

Keywords

Sign Up for INFORMS Publications Updates and News