Fair Allocation of Vaccines, Ventilators and Antiviral Treatments: Leaving No Ethical Value Behind in Healthcare Rationing

References

• Abdulkadiroğlu A (2005) College admissions with affirmative action. Internat. J. Game Theory 33(4):535–549.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Abdulkadiroğlu A, Sönmez T (2003) School choice: A mechanism design approach. Amer. Econom. Rev. 93:729–747.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Akbarpour M, Budish E, Dworczak P, Kominers SD (2023) An economic framework for vaccine prioritization. Quart. J. Econom., ePub ahead of print June 12, https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjad022.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Ariadne Labs (2020) Symposium: Vaccine allocation and social justice. Accessed January 2023, https://www.ariadnelabs.org/2020/12/08/symposium-vaccine-allocation-and-social-justice/.Google Scholar
• Aygün O, Bó I (2021) College admission with multidimensional privileges: The Brazilian affirmative action case. Amer. Econom. J. Microeconom. 13(3):1–28.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Azevedo E, Leshno J (2016) A supply and demand framework for two-sided matching markets. J. Polit. Econom. 124(5):1235–1268.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Aziz H, Brandl F (2021) Efficient, fair, and incentive-compatible healthcare rationing. Preprint, submitted February 8, https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.04384.Google Scholar
• Balinski M, Sönmez T (1999) A tale of two mechanisms: Student placement. J. Econom. Theory 84:73–94.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Baswana S, Chakrabarti, PP, Chandran S, Kanoria Y, Patange U (2019) Centralized admissions for engineering Colleges in India. INFORMS J. Appl. Anal. 49(5):307–396.Google Scholar
• Biddinger P (2020) Interview. Conducted on December 18.Google Scholar
• Biro P, Fleiner T, Irving RW, Manlove DF (2010) The college admissions problem with lower and common quotas. Theor. Comput. Sci. 411(34–36):3136–3153.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bo I (2016) Fair implementation of diversity in school choice. Games Econom. Behav. 97:54–63.Crossref, Google Scholar
• CDC (2018) Interim planning guidance on allocating and targeting pandemic influenza vaccine during an influenza pandemic. Accessed July 1, 2020, https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/pdf/2018-Influenza-Guidance.pdf.Google Scholar
• Combe J (2018) Are affirmative action policies so impossible? Rev. Econom. Polit. 128(6):1123–1173.Google Scholar
• Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (2020) Ethical allocation framework for emerging treatments of COVID-19. Accessed January 2023, https://www.health.pa.gov/topics/disease/coronavirus/Pages/Guidance/Ethical-Allocation-Framework.aspx.Google Scholar
• Correa J, Epstein R, Escobar J, Rios I, Bahamondes B, Bonet C, Epstein N, et al. (2019) School choice in Chile. EC’19 Proc. 2019 ACM Conf. Econom. Comput. (Association for Computing Machinery, New York), 325–343.Google Scholar
• Daugherty-Biddison L, Gwon H, Regenberg A, Schoch-Spana M, Toner E (2017) Maryland framework for the allocation of scarce life-sustaining medical resources in a catastrophic public health emergency. Accessed January 2023, https://www.law.umaryland.edu/media/SOL/pdfs/Programs/Health-Law/MHECN/ASR\%20Framework\_Final.pdf.Google Scholar
• de Puy Kamp M, Devine C, Griffin D (2020) As coronavirus cases grow, hospitals adopt a system to rank patients for treatment. CNN (April 3), https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/03/health/coronavirus-hospital-ethics-ventilators-invs/index.html.Google Scholar
• Delacrétaz D (2021) Processing reserves simultaneously. Working paper, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.Google Scholar
• DHS Arizona (2020) COVID-19 addendum: Allocation of scarce resources in acute care facilities. Accessed July 4, 2020, http://azpha.wildapricot.org/resources/covid-19-addendum.pdf.Google Scholar
• Doğan B (2016) Responsive affirmative action in school choice. J. Econom. Theory 165:69–105.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Doğan B (2017) How to control controlled school choice: Comment. Amer. Econom. Rev. 107(4):1362–1364.Crossref, Google Scholar
• DPH (2020a) Crisis standards of care planning guidance for the COVID-19 pandemic. Accessed January 2023, https://d279m997dpfwgl.cloudfront.net/wp/2020/04/CSC_April-7_2020.pdf.Google Scholar
• DPH (2020b) Crisis standards of care planning guidance for the COVID-19 pandemic (revised). Accessed January 2023, https://www.mass.gov/doc/crisis-standards-of-care-planning-guidance-for-the-covid-19-pandemic-0/download.Google Scholar
• Dur U, Morrill T, Phan W (2021) Allocating medical resources during a pandemic. Working paper, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC.Google Scholar
• Dur U, Pathak PA, Sönmez T (2020) Explicit vs. statistical preferential treatment in affirmative action: Theory and evidence from Chicago’s exam schools. J. Econom. Theory 187:104996.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Dur U, Kominers SD, Pathak PA, Sönmez T (2018) Reserve design: Unintended consequences and the demise of Boston’s walk zones. J. Polit. Econom. 126:2457–2479.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Echenique F, Yenmez MB (2015) How to control controlled school choice. Amer. Econom. Rev. 105(8):2679–2694.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Ehlers L, Morrill T (2019) (Il)legal assignments in school choice. Rev. Econom. Stud. 87(4):1837–1875.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Ehlers L, Hafalir IE, Yenmez MB, Yildirim MA (2014) School choice with controlled choice constraints: Hard bounds versus soft bounds. J. Econom. Theory 153:648–683.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Emanuel EJ, Persad G, Upshur R, Thome B, Parker M, Glickman A, Zhang C, et al. (2020) Fair allocation of scarce medical resources in the time of COVID-19. N. Engl. J. Med. 382(21):2049–2055.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Fink S (2020) U.S. Civil Rights Office rejects rationing medical care based on disability, age. New York Times (March 28), https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/28/us/coronavirus-disabilities-rationing-ventilators-triage.html.Google Scholar
• Fragiadakis D, Troyan P (2017) Improving matching under hard distributional constraints. Theor. Econom. 12(2):863–908.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Gale D, Shapley LS (1962) College admissions and the stability of marriage. Amer. Math. Monthly 69:9–15.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Goto M, Kojima F, Kurata R, Tamura A, Yokoo M (2017) Designing matching mechanisms under general distributional constraints. Amer. Econom. J. Microeconom. 9(2):226–262.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Greenberg K, Pathak PA, Sönmez T (2023) Redesigning the US Army’s branching process: A case study in minimalist market design. Preprint, submitted March 15, https://arxiv.org/abs/2303.06564.Google Scholar
• Grigoryan A (2021) Effective, fair and equitable pandemic rationing. Preprint, submitted October 6, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3646539.Google Scholar
• Hafalir IE, Yenmez MB, Yildirim MA (2013) Effective affirmative action in school choice. Theor. Econom. 8(2):325–363.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hellman D, Nicholson KM (2021) Rationing and disability: The civil rights and wrongs of state triage protocols. Washington Lee Law Rev. 78(4).Google Scholar
• Hitzig Z (2020) The normative gap: Mechanism design and ideal theories of justice. Econom. Philos. 36(3):407–434.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hopcroft JE, Karp RM (1973) An n5/2 algorithm for maximum matchings in bipartite graphs. SIAM J. Comput. 2:225–231.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Imamura K (2020) Meritocracy versus diversity. Working paper, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, MA.Google Scholar
• Jones AE, Trzeciak S, Kline JA (2009) The Sequential Organ Failure Assessment score for predicting outcome in patients with severe sepsis and evidence of hypoperfusion at the time of emergency department presentation. Crit. Care Med. 37:1649–1654.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kamada Y, Kojima F (2015) Efficient matching under distributional constraints: Theory and applications. Amer. Econom. Rev. 105(1):67–99.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kamada Y, Kojima F (2017) Stability concepts in matching with distributional constraints. J. Econom. Theory 168:107–142.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kamada Y, Kojima F (2018) Stability and strategy-proofness for matching with constraints: A necessary and sufficient condition. Theor. Econom. 13(2):761–794.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Karzanov AV (1973) An exact estimate of an algorithm for finding a maximum flow, applied to the problem on representatives. Problems Cybernetics 5:66–70.Google Scholar
• Kinlaw K, Levine R (2007) Ethical guidelines in pandemic influenza: Recommendations of the Ethics Subcommittee of the Advisory Committee to the Director. Report, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta.Google Scholar
• Kojima F (2012) School choice: Impossibilities for affirmative action. Games Econom. Behav. 75(2):685–693.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kojima F, Tamura A, Yokoo M (2018) Designing matching mechanisms under constraints: An approach from discrete convex analysis. J. Econom. Theory 176:803–833.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kominers SD, Sönmez T (2016) Matching with slot-specific priorities: Theory. Theor. Econom. 11(2):683–710.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kowalczyk L (2020) Who gets a ventilator? New gut-wrenching state guidelines issued on rationing equipment. Boston Globe (April 7), https://www.bostonglobe.com/2020/04/07/metro/massachusetts-officials-release-plan-ration-ventilators-icu-beds-if-need-arises/.Google Scholar
• Kuhn HW (1955) The Hungarian Method for the assignment problem. Naval Res. Logist. Quart. 2:83–97.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Lee T (2004) Rationing influenza vaccine. N. Engl. J. Med. 351:2365–2366.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Li S (2017) Ethics and market design. Oxford Rev. Econom. Policy 33(4):705–720.Crossref, Google Scholar
• MA DPH (2020a) MA COVID-19 vaccine presentation. Accessed January 2023, https://www.mass.gov/doc/ma-covid-19-vaccine-presentation-1292020/download.Google Scholar
• MA DPH (2020b) Massachusetts Department of Public Health guidance for allocation of COVID-19 monoclonal antibody therapeutics. Accessed January 2023, https://www.mass.gov/doc/guidance-for-allocation-of-covid-19-monoclonal-antibody-therapeutics/download.Google Scholar
• Makhoul AT, Drolet BC (2021) Reserve system implementation during the COVID-19 pandemic. Chest 160(6):2005–2006.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Mendelsohn NS, Dulmage AL (1958) Some generalizations of the problem of distinct representatives. Canad. J. Math. 10:230–241.Crossref, Google Scholar
• NASEM (2020a) A framework for equitable allocation of vaccine for the novel coronavirus. Accessed January 2023, https://www.nap.edu/resource/25917/25914.pdf.Google Scholar
• NASEM (2020b) A framework for equitable allocation of vaccine for the novel coronavirus. Accessed January 2023, https://www.nationalacademies.org/our-work/a-framework-for-equitable-allocation-of-vaccine-for-the-novel-coronavirus.Google Scholar
• Ne’eman A (2020) I will not apologize for my needs. New York Times (March 23), https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/23/opinion/coronavirus-ventilators-triage-disability.html.Google Scholar
• ORAAC (2023) Request for public input. Accessed January 2023, https://www.oregon.gov/oha/ORAACDocuments/ORAAC\%20Request\%20for\%20Public\%20Comment_EN.pdf.Google Scholar
• Pathak PA, Rees-Jones A, Sönmez T (2023a) Immigration lottery design: Engineered and coincidental consequences of H-1B reforms. Rev. Econom. Statist. Forthcoming.Google Scholar
• Pathak PA, Rees-Jones A, Sönmez T (2023b) Reversing reserves. Management Sci. Forthcoming.Link, Google Scholar
• Pathak PA, Sönmez T, Ünver MU (2020a) Improving ventilator rationing through collaboration with experts on resource allocation. JAMA Netw. Open 3(6):e2012838.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Pathak PA, Sönmez T, Ünver MU, Yenmez MB (2020b) Leaving no ethical value behind: Triage protocol design for pandemic rationing. NBER Working Paper 26951, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Pathak PA, Schmidt H, Solomon A, Song E, Sönmez T, Ünver MU (2020c) Do Black and Indigenous communities receive their fair share of vaccines under the 2018 CDC guidelines? NBER Working Paper 27817, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Persad G, Peek ME, Emanuel E (2020) Fairly prioritizing groups for access to COVID-19 vaccines. JAMA 324(16):1601–1602.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Piscitello GM, Miller WD, Kapania EM, Rojas JC, Siegler M, Parker WF (2020) Systematic review of the variation in U.S. state ventilator allocation guidelines during a public health crisis. JAMA Netw. Open 3:e2012606.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Prehn AW, Vawter D (2008) Ethical guidance for rationing scarce health-related resources in a severe influenza pandemic: Literature and plan review. Report, Minnesota Pandemic Ethics Project, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
• Richmond City (2021a) Phase 2 is now open in Richmond and Henrico! Accessed January 2023, https://www.vdh.virginia.gov/richmond-city/2021/04/08/phase-2-is-now-open-in-richmond-and-henrico/.Google Scholar
• Richmond City (2021b) Richmond and Henrico Health Districts expand vaccine eligibility to all Phase 1b groups. Accessed January 2023, https://www.vdh.virginia.gov/richmond-city/phase-1b-expansion/.Google Scholar
• Rosenbaum L (2020) Facing COVID-19 in Italy—Ethics, logistics, and therapeutics on the epidemic’s front line. N. Engl. J. Med. 382(20):1873–1875.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Rubin E, Dryden-Peterson SL, Hammond SP, Lennes I, Letourneau AR, Pathak PA, Sönmez T, Ünver MU (2021) A novel approach to equitable distribution of scarce therapeutics: Institutional experience implementing a reserve system for allocation of COVID-19 monoclonal antibodies. Chest 160(6):2324–2331.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Schmidt H (2020) Vaccine rationing and the urgency of social justice in the COVID-19 response. Hastings Center Rep. 50:1–4.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Schmidt H, Pathak P, Sönmez T, Ünver MU (2020) COVID-19: How to prioritize worse-off populations in allocating safe and effective vaccines. BMJ 371:m3795.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Schmidt H, Weintraub R, Williams MA, Miller K, Buttenheim A, Sadecki E, Wu H, et al. (2021) Equitable allocation of COVID-19 vaccines in the United States. Nat. Med. 27:1298–1307.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Schoch-Spana M, Fitzgerald J, Kramer BR, UPMC Influenza Task Force (2005) Influenza vaccine scarcity 2004–05: Implications for biosecurity and public health preparedness. Biosecurity Bioterrorism 3(3):224–234.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Schrijver A (2003) Combinatorial Optimization: Polyhendra and Efficiency, vol. A (Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg).Google Scholar
• Sönmez T (2023) Minimalist market design: A framework for economists with policy aspirations. Working paper, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, MA; https://www.tayfunsonmez.net/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/Minimalist-Market-Design-February2023.pdf.Google Scholar
• Sönmez T, Yenmez MB (2022) Affirmative action in India via vertical, horizontal, and overlapping reservations. Econometrica 90(3):1143–1176.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Sönmez T, Pathak PA, Ünver MU, Persad G, Truog RD, White DB (2021) Categorized priority systems: A new tool for fairly allocating scarce medical resources in the face of profound social inequities. Chest 159:1294–1299.Crossref, Google Scholar
• TDH (2020a) COVID-19 vaccination plan, version 1.0, October 16. Accessed January 2023, https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/covid-19/downloads/tennessee-jurisdiction-executive-summary.pdf.Google Scholar
• TDH (2020b) COVID-19 vaccination plan, version 3.0, December 30. Accessed January 2023, https://www.tn.gov/content/dam/tn/health/documents/cedep/novel-coronavirus/COVID-19_Vaccination_Plan.pdf.Google Scholar
• Tomoeda K (2018) Finding a stable matching under type-specific minimum quotas. J. Econom. Theory 176:81–117.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Truog RD, Mitchell C, Daley GQ (2020) The toughest triage—Allocating ventilators in a pandemic. N. Engl. J. Med. 382:1973–1975.Crossref, Google Scholar
• University of Pittsburgh (2020) Allocation of scarce critical care resources during a public health emergency. School of Medicine, Department of Critical Care Medicine.Google Scholar
• Vawter DE, Garrett JE, Gervais KG, Prehn AW, DeBruin DA, Tauer CA, Parilla E, et al. (2010) For the good of us all: Ethically rationing health resources in Minnesota in a severe influenza pandemic. Minnesota Pandemic Ethics Project, Minnesota Department of Health, St. Paul, MN.Google Scholar
• Vincent JL, Moreno R, Takala J, Willatts S, De Mendonça A, Bruining H, Reinhart CK, et al. (1996) The SOFA (Sepsis-related Organ Failure Assessment) score to describe organ dysfunction/failure. On behalf of the Working Group on Sepsis-Related Problems of the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine. Intensive Care Med. 22:707–710.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Wasserman D, Persad G, Millum J (2020) Setting priorities fairly in response to COVID-19: Identifying overlapping consensus and reasonable disagreement. J. Law Biosci. 7(1):lsaa044.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Westkamp A (2013) An analysis of the German university admissions system. Econom. Theory. 53(3):561–589.Crossref, Google Scholar
• White DB, Katz MH, Luce JM, Lo B (2009) Who should receive life support during a public health emergency? Using ethical principles to improve allocation decisions. Ann. Intern. Med. 150(2):132–138.Crossref, Google Scholar
• White DB, McCreary EK, Chang C-CH, Schmidhofer M, Bariola JR, Jonassaint NN, Persad G, et al. (2022) A multicenter weighted lottery to equitably allocate scarce COVID-19 therapeutics. Amer. J. Respiratory Crit. Care Med. 206(4):503–506.Crossref, Google Scholar
• WHO (2007) Ethical considerations in developing a public health response to pandemic influenza. Accessed January 2023, http://www.who.int/csr/resources/publications/WHO\_CDS\_EPR\_GIP\_2007\_2/en/index.html.Google Scholar
• Whyte LE (2020) State policies may send people with disabilities to the back of the line for ventilators. Accessed January 2023, https://publicintegrity.org/health/coronavirus-and-inequality/state-policies-may-send-people-with-disabilities-to-the-back-of-the-line-for-ventilators/.Google Scholar
• Wu E-L, Kumar RN, Moore WJ, Hall GT, Vysniauskaite I, Kim K-YA, Angarone MP, et al. (2022) Disparities in COVID-19 monoclonal antibody delivery: A retrospective cohort study. J. Gen. Intern. Med. 37(10):2505–2513.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Zucker HA, Adler KP, Berens DP, Brynner R, Butler K, Calderon Y, Corcoran C, et al. (2015) Ventilator allocation guidelines. New York State Task Force on Life and the Law, New York Department of Health, New York.Google Scholar