Should Human Capital Development Programs be Mandatory or Voluntary? Evidence from a Field Experiment on Mentorship

References

• Acemoglu D , Pischke JS (1999) The structure of wages and investment in general training. J. Political Econom. 107(3):539–572.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Allcott H (2015) Site selection bias in program evaluation. Quart. J. Econom. 130(3):1117–1165.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Allen TD , Eby LT , Chao GT , Bauer TN (2017) Taking stock of two relational aspects of organizational life: Tracing the history and shaping the future of socialization and mentoring research. J. Appl. Psych. 102(3):324–337.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Anderson ML (2008) Multiple inference and gender differences in the effects of early intervention: A reevaluation of the abecedarian, perry preschool, and early training projects. J. Amer. Statist. Assoc. 103(484):1481–1495.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Ashraf N , Bandiera O , Minni V , Zingales L (2025) Meaning at work. NBER Working Paper No. 33843, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Bandiera O , Barankay I , Rasul I (2013) Team incentives: Evidence from a firm-level experiment. J. Eur. Econom. Assoc. 11(5):1079–1114.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bandiera O , Prat A , Hansen S , Sadun R (2020) Ceo behavior and firm performance. J. Political Econom. 128(4):1325–1369.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Becker GS (1975) Human Capital: A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis, with Special Reference to Education (University of Chicago Press, Chicago).Google Scholar
• Benmelech E , Bergman N , Kim H (2022) Strong employers and weak employees: How does employer concentration affect wages? J. Hum. Res. 57(S):S200‒S250.Google Scholar
• Benson A , Li D , Shue K (2019) Promotions and the peter principle. Quart. J. Econom. 134(4):2085–2134.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Benson A , Li D , Shue K (2024) Potential and the gender promotions gap. Preprint, submitted April 2, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4747175.Google Scholar
• Bertrand M , Schoar A (2003) Managing with style: The effect of managers on firm policies. Quart. J. Econom. 118(4):1169–1208.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bloom N , Van Reenen J (2007) Measuring and explaining management practices across firms and countries. Quart. J. Econom. 122(4):1351–1408.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bloom N , Sadun R , Van Reenen J (2016) Management as a technology? NBER Working Paper No. 22327, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bloom N , Liang J , Roberts J , Ying ZJ (2015) Does working from home work? Evidence from a Chinese experiment. Quart. J. Econom. 130(1):165–218.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bloom N , Lemos R , Sadun R , Scur D , Van Reenen J (2014) Jeea-fbbva lecture 2013: The new empirical economics of management. J. Eur. Econom. Assoc. 12(4):835–876.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bloom N , Brynjolfsson E , Foster L , Jarmin R , Patnaik M , Saporta-Eksten I , Van Reenen J (2019) What drives differences in management practices? Amer. Econom. Rev. 109(5):1648–1683.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bojinov I , Choudhury PN , Lane J (2021) Virtual watercoolers: A field experiment on virtual synchronous interactions and performance of organizational newcomers. Harvard Business School Technology & Operations Mgt. Unit Working Paper (21-125).Google Scholar
• Brynjolfsson E , Li D , Raymond LR (2023) Generative AI at work. NBER Working Paper No. 31161, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Carrell SE , Sacerdote BI , West JE (2013) From natural variation to optimal policy? The importance of endogenous peer group formation. Econometrica 81(3):855–882.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Carter SP , Dudley W , Lyle DS , Smith JZ (2019) Who’s the boss? The effect of strong leadership on employee turnover. J. Econom. Behav. Organ. 159:323–343.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Castro S , Englmaier F , Guadalupe M (2022) Fostering psychological safety in teams: Evidence from an RCT. Preprint, submitted June 20, http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4141538.Google Scholar
• Chan DC , Gentzkow M , Yu C (2022) Selection with variation in diagnostic skill: Evidence from radiologists. Quart. J. Econom. 137(2):729–783.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Chandrasekhar AG , Golub B , Yang H (2018) Signaling, shame, and silence in social learning. NBER Working Paper No. 25169, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Chatterji A , Delecourt S , Hasan S , Koning R (2019) When does advice impact startup performance? Strategic Management J. 40(3):331–356.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Chetty R , Friedman JN , Rockoff JE (2014) Measuring the impacts of teachers II: Teacher value-added and student outcomes in adulthood. Amer. Econom. Rev. 104(9):2633–2679.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Cornelissen T , Dustmann C , Schönberg U (2017) Peer effects in the workplace. Amer. Econom. Rev. 107(2):425–456.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Cornwell C , Schmutte IM , Scur D (2021) Building a productive workforce: The role of structured management practices. Management Sci. 67(12):7308–7321.Link, Google Scholar
• Coviello D , Ichino A , Persico N (2014) Time allocation and task juggling. Amer. Econom. Rev. 104(2):609–623.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Currie J , MacLeod WB (2017) Diagnosing expertise: Human capital, decision making, and performance among physicians. J. Labor Econom. 35(1):1–43.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Currie JM , MacLeod WB (2020) Understanding doctor decision making: The case of depression treatment. Econometrica. 88(3):847–878.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Custódio C , Ferreira MA , Matos P (2019) Do general managerial skills spur innovation? Management Sci. 65(2):459–476.Link, Google Scholar
• Dahl GB , Løken KV , Mogstad M (2014) Peer effects in program participation. Amer. Econom. Rev. 104(7):2049–2074.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Del Carpio L , Guadalupe M (2022) More women in tech? Evidence from a field experiment addressing social identity. Management Sci. 68(5):3196–3218.Link, Google Scholar
• Delfino A , Garnero A , Inferrera S , Leonardi M , Sadun R (2024) Unwilling to reskill? Evidence from a survey experiment with jobseekers.Google Scholar
• DellaVigna S , List JA , Malmendier U (2012) Testing for altruism and social pressure in charitable giving. Quart. J. Econom. 127(1):1–56. ISSN 00335533, https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjr050.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Deming DJ , Hastings JS , Kane TJ , Staiger DO (2014) School choice, school quality, and postsecondary attainment. Amer. Econom. Rev. 104(3):991–1013.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Diaz B , Neyra-Nazarrett A , Ramirez J , Sadun R , Tamayo J (2025) Training within firms. NBER Working Paper No. 33670, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Edmans A (2011) Does the stock market fully value intangibles? Employee satisfaction and equity prices. J. Financial Econom. 101(3):621–640.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Edmondson AC , Lei Z (2014) Psychological safety: The history, renaissance, and future of an interpersonal construct. Annual Rev. Org. Psych. Org. Behav. 1(1):23–43.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Emanuel N , Harrington E , Pallais A (2023) The power of proximity to coworkers: Training for tomorrow or productivity today? NBER Working Paper No. 31880, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Englmaier F , Foss NJ , Knudsen T , Kretschmer T (2018) Organization design and firm heterogeneity: Towards an integrated research agenda for strategy. Organization Design (Emerald Publishing Limited, Bingley, UK), 229–252.Google Scholar
• Englmaier F , Grimm S , Grothe D , Schindler D , Schudy S (2025) The value of leadership: Evidence from a large-scale field experiment. Leadership Quart. 36(3):101869.Google Scholar
• Finkelstein A , Gentzkow M , Williams H (2016) Sources of geographic variation in health care: Evidence from patient migration. Quart. J. Econom. 131(4):1681–1726.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Friebel G , Heinz M , Zubanov N (2022) Middle managers, personnel turnover, and performance: A long-term field experiment in a retail chain. Management Sci. 68(1):211–229.Link, Google Scholar
• Friebel G , Heinz M , Hoffman M , Zubanov N (2023) What do employee referral programs do? Measuring the direct and overall effects of a management practice. J. Political Econom. 131(3):633–686.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Friebel G , Heinz M , Krueger M , Zubanov N (2017) Team incentives and performance: Evidence from a retail chain. Amer. Econom. Rev. 107(8):2168–2203.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Fudenberg D , Rayo L (2019) Training and effort dynamics in apprenticeship. Amer. Econom. Rev. 109(11):3780–3812.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Gibbons R , Henderson R (2013) What Do Managers Do? Exploring Persistent Performance Differences Among Seemingly Similar Enterprises (Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ), 680–731.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Ginther DK , Currie JM , Blau FD , Croson RT (2020) Can mentoring help female assistant professors in economics? An evaluation by randomized trial. AEA Papers Proc. 110:205–209.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Gosnell GK , List JA , Metcalfe RD (2020) The impact of management practices on employee productivity: A field experiment with airline captains. J. Political Econom. 128(4):1195–1233.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Gubler T , Larkin I , Pierce L (2018) Doing well by making well: The impact of corporate wellness programs on employee productivity. Management Sci. 64(11):4967–4987.Link, Google Scholar
• Gutner T (2009) Finding anchors in the storm: Mentors. Wall Street J. (January 27), https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB123301451869117603?msockid=11735632ab496b95126d43ceaa2b6a03.Google Scholar
• Heckman JJ , Ichimura H , Todd PE (1997) Matching as an econometric evaluation estimator: Evidence from evaluating a job training programme. Rev. Econom. Stud. 64(4):605–654.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Herbst D , Mas A (2015) Peer effects on worker output in the laboratory generalize to the field. Science. 350(6260):545–549.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Heursen L , Friess S , Chugunova M (2023) Reputational concerns and advice-seeking at work. Max Planck Institute for Innovation & Competition Research Paper, No. 23-17, Max Planck Institute for Innovation and Competition, Munich, Germany.Google Scholar
• Hilmer C , Hilmer M (2007) Women helping women, men helping women? Same-gender mentoring, initial job placements, and early career publishing success for economics PhDs. Amer. Econom. Rev. 97(2):422–426.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hoffman M , Burks SV (2020) Worker overconfidence: Field evidence and implications for employee turnover and firm profits. Quant. Econom. 11(1):315–348.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hoffman M , Stanton CT (2024) People, practices, and productivity: A review of new advances in personnel economics. NBER Working Paper No. 32849, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Hoffman M , Tadelis S (2021) People management skills, employee attrition, and manager rewards: An empirical analysis. J. Political Econom. 129(1):243–285.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hoffman M , Kahn LB , Li D (2017) Discretion in hiring. Quart. J. Econom. 133(2):765–800.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hong F , Hossain T , List JA (2015) Framing manipulations in contests: A natural field experiment. J. Econom. Behav. Organ. 118:372–382.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Hossain T , List JA (2012) The behavioralist visits the factory: Increasing productivity using simple framing manipulations. Management Sci. 58(12):2151–2167.Link, Google Scholar
• Huffman D , Raymond C , Shvets J (2022) Persistent overconfidence and biased memory: Evidence from managers. Amer. Econom. Rev. 112(10):3141–3175.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Johnson MS , Levine DI , Toffel MW (2023) Improving regulatory effectiveness through better targeting: Evidence from OSHA. Amer. Econom. J. Appl. Econom. 15(4):30–67.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Jones D , Molitor D , Reif J (2019) What do workplace wellness programs do? Evidence from the Illinois workplace wellness study. Quart. J. Econom. 134(4):1747–1791.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Karlan D , Zinman J (2009) Observing unobservables: Identifying information asymmetries with a consumer credit field experiment. Econometrica 77(6):1993–2008.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Larkin I (2014) The cost of high-powered incentives: Employee gaming in enterprise software sales. J. Labor Econom. 32(2):199–227.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Larkin I , Leider S (2012) Incentive schemes, sorting and behavorial biases of employees: Experimental evidence. Amer. Econom. J. Microeconom. 4(2):184–214.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Larrain M (2015) Capital account opening and wage inequality. Rev. Financial Stud. 28(6):1555–1587.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Lazear EP , Malmendier U , Weber RA (2012) Sorting in experiments with application to social preferences. Amer. Econom. J. Appl. Econom. 4(1):136–163.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Lazear EP , Shaw KL , Stanton C (2016) Making do with less: Working harder during recessions. J. Labor Econom. 34(S1):S333–S360.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Lazear EP , Shaw KL , Stanton CT (2015) The value of bosses. J. Labor Econom. 33(4):823–861.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Lee DS (2009) Training, wages, and sample selection: Estimating sharp bounds on treatment effects. Rev. Econom. Stud. 76(3):1071–1102.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Li D , Raymond LR , Bergman P (2025) Hiring as exploration. Rev. Economic Stud. rdaf040.Google Scholar
• List JA (2020) Non est disputandum de generalizability? A glimpse into the external validity trial. NBER Working Paper No. 27535, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Crossref, Google Scholar
• List JA (2022) The Voltage Effect: How to Make Good Ideas Great and Great Ideas Scale (Crown Currency, New York).Google Scholar
• Lyle DS , Smith JZ (2014) The effect of high-performing mentors on junior officer promotion in the us army. J. Labor Econom. 32(2):229–258.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Mas A , Moretti E (2009) Peers at work. Amer. Econom. Rev. 99(1):112–145.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Metcalfe RD , Sollaci AB , Syverson C (2023) Managers and productivity in retail. NBER Working Paper No. 31192, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Minni V (2023) Making the invisible hand visible: Managers and the allocation of workers to jobs. Working paper, Chicago Booth.Google Scholar
• Nishesh N , Ouimet P , Simintzi E (2024) Labor and corporate finance. Handbook of Corporate Finance (Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, UK), 647–673.Google Scholar
• Oyer P (1998) Fiscal year ends and nonlinear incentive contracts: The effect on business seasonality. Quart. J. Econom. 113(1):149–185.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Oyer P , Schaefer S (2011) Personnel economics: Hiring and incentives. Handbook of Labor Econom. 4:1769–1823.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Reif J , Chan D , Jones D , Payne L , Molitor D (2020) Effects of a workplace wellness program on employee health, health beliefs, and medical use: A randomized clinical trial. JAMA Internal Med. 180(7):952–960.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Rockoff JE (2008) Does mentoring reduce turnover and improve skills of new employees? Evidence from teachers in New York City. NBER Working Paper No. 13868, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.Google Scholar
• Rouen E , Regier M (2022) The stock market value of human capital creation. Harvard Business School Accounting & Management Unit Working Paper (21–047).Google Scholar
• Ruggles S, Flood S, Sobek M, Backman D, Cooper G, Rivera Drew JA, Richards S, Rogers R, Schroeder J, Williams KCW (2025) IPUMS USA: Version 16.0 [American Community Survey dataset], IPUMS, Minneapolis.Google Scholar
• Sandvik JJ , Saouma RE , Seegert NT , Stanton CT (2020) Workplace knowledge flows. Quart. J. Econom. 135(3):1635–1680.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Starr E (2019) Consider this: Training, wages, and the enforceability of covenants not to compete. ILR Rev. 72(4):783–817.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Statista (2022) Total training expenditures in the United States from 2012 to 2022 (in billion U.S. dollars) [graph]. Accessed January 29, 2023, https://www-statista-com.ezp-prod1.hul.harvard.edu/statistics/788521/training-expenditures-united-states/.Google Scholar
• Syverson C (2011) What determines productivity? J. Econom. Lit. 49(2):326–365.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Walters CR (2018) The demand for effective charter schools. J. Political Econom. 126(6):2179–2223.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Zingales L (2000) In search of new foundations. J. Finance 55(4):1623–1653.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Zivin JG , Kahn LB , Neidell M (2021) Incentivizing learning-by-doing: The role of compensation schemes. Workplace Productivity and Management Practices , 139–178 (Emerald Publishing Limited, Leeds, UK).Crossref, Google Scholar