Frontiers in Operations: Bounding Counterfactual Outcomes of Health Insurance Delay-and-Deny Practices

References

• Alagoz O, Ayer T, Erenay FS (2010) Operations research models for cancer screening. Cochran JJ, Cox V, Keskinocak P, Kharoufeh JP, Smith JC, eds. Wiley Encyclopedia of Operations Research and Management Science (Wiley, Hoboken, NJ).Google Scholar
• Anjos MF, Lasserre JB (2011) Handbook on Semidefinite, Conic and Polynomial Optimization, vol. 166 (Springer Science & Business Media, New York).Google Scholar
• Ayer T, Alagoz O, Stout NK (2012) A POMDP approach to personalize mammography screening decisions. Oper. Res. 60(5):1019–1034.Link, Google Scholar
• Balke A, Pearl J (1994) Counterfactual probabilities: Computational methods, bounds and applications. de Mántaras LR, Poole D, eds. Proc. 10th Conf. Uncertainty Artificial Intelligence (Morgan Kaufmann Publishers Inc., San Francisco), 46–54. Crossref, Google Scholar
• Barber D (2012) Bayesian Reasoning and Machine Learning (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK).Crossref, Google Scholar
• Bertsimas D, Imai K, Li ML (2022) Distributionally robust causal inference with observational data. Preprint, submitted October 15, https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.08326.Google Scholar
• Biniek J, Sroczynski N, Tricia N (2024) Use of prior authorization in Medicare advantage exceeded 46 million requests in 2022. KFF (January 28), https://www.kff.org/medicare/issue-brief/use-of-prior-authorization-in-medicare-advantage-exceeded-46-million-requests-in-2022/.Google Scholar
• Bishop CM (2006) Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning, Information Science and Statistics (Springer, New York).Google Scholar
• Buesing L, Weber T, Zwols Y, Heess N, Racaniere S, Guez A, Lespiau JB (2019) Woulda, Coulda, Shoulda: Counterfactually-guided policy search. Internat. Conf. Learn. Representations (Curran Associates, Inc., Red Hook, NY).Google Scholar
• Cai Z, Kuroki M (2005) Variance estimators for three “probabilities of causation”. Risk Anal. (Oxford) 25(6):1611–1620.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Chaffin J, Wernau J (2024) Doctors say dealing with health insurers is only getting worse. Wall Street Journal (December 12), https://www.wsj.com/health/healthcare/doctor-physician-health-insurance-companies-anger-6f23b470.Google Scholar
• Cox DR (1972) Regression models and life-tables. J. Roy. Statist. Soc.: Ser. B (Methodological) 34(2):187–220.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Duarte G, Finkelstein N, Knox D, Mummolo J, Shpitser I (2024) An automated approach to causal inference in discrete settings. J. Amer. Statist. Assoc. 119(547):1778–1793.Google Scholar
• Eberhardt F, Kaynar N, Siddiq A (2025) Discovering causal models with optimization: Confounders, cycles, and instrument validity. Management Sci. 71(4):3283–3302.Link, Google Scholar
• Eckholm E (1993) $89 million awarded family who sued H.M.O. New York Times (December 30), https://www.nytimes.com/1993/12/30/us/89-million-awarded-family-who-sued-hmo.html.Google Scholar
• Freed M, Biniek J, Damico A, Neuman T (2024) Medicare advantage in 2024. KFF (August 8), https://www.kff.org/medicare/medicare-advantage-in-2024-enrollment-update-and-key-trends/.Google Scholar
• Greenland S (1999) Relation of probability of causation to relative risk and doubling dose: A methodologic error that has become a social problem. Amer. J. Public Health 89(8):1166–1169.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Grimm C (2022) Some Medicare advantage organization denials of prior authorization requests raise concerns about beneficiary access to medically necessary care. Office of Inspector General (April 27), https://oig.hhs.gov/reports/all/2022/some-medicare-advantage-organization-denials-of-prior-authorization-requests-raise-concerns-about-beneficiary-access-to-medically-necessary-care/.Google Scholar
• Haugh M, Singal R (2023) Counterfactual analysis in dynamic latent state models. Internat. Conf. Machine Learn. (PMLR, New York).Google Scholar
• Haugh M, Singal R (2026) A counterfactual analysis of the dishonest casino. J. Causal Inference Forthcoming.Google Scholar
• Huff D (2024) Judge rules HMSA contracts are ‘unconscionable’ in lawsuit from doctors and patients. Hawaii News Now (February 14), https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2024/02/15/judge-rules-hmsa-contracts-are-unconscionable-lawsuit-doctors-patients/.Google Scholar
• IBM (2017) ILOG CPLEX Optimizer Version 12.8.Google Scholar
• Johnstone PA, Norton MS, Riffenburgh RH (2000) Survival of patients with untreated breast cancer. J. Surgical Oncology 73(4):273–277.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Kaplan EL, Meier P (1958) Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations. J. Amer. Statist. Assoc. 53(282):457–481.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Lagakos SW, Mosteller F (1986) Assigned shares in compensation for radiation-related cancers. Risk Anal. (Oxford) 6(3):345–357.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Maillart LM, Ivy JS, Ransom S, Diehl K (2008) Assessing dynamic breast cancer screening policies. Oper. Res. 56(6):1411–1427.Link, Google Scholar
• Manski CF (1990) Nonparametric bounds on treatment effects. Amer. Econom. Rev. 80(2):319–323.Google Scholar
• Mathews A (2024) After UnitedHealthcare CEO killing, doctors speak out. Wall Street Journal (December 13), https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0zV9qk5rIaM.Google Scholar
• MATLAB (2021) MATLAB Version 9.10.0 (R2021b) (The MathWorks Inc., Natick, MA).Google Scholar
• Miller TC, Rucker P, Armstrong D (2024) “Not medically necessary”: Inside the company helping America’s biggest health insurers deny coverage for care. ProPublica (October 23), https://www.propublica.org/article/evicore-health-insurance-denials-cigna-unitedhealthcare-aetna-prior-authorizations.Google Scholar
• Mole B (2023) UnitedHealth uses AI model with 90% error rate to deny care, lawsuit alleges. Ars Technica (November 17), https://arstechnica.com/health/2023/11/ai-with-90-error-rate-forces-elderly-out-of-rehab-nursing-homes-suit-claims.Google Scholar
• Mueller S, Li A, Pearl J (2022) Causes of effects: Learning individual responses from population data. Internat. Joint Conf. Artificial Intelligence (ijcai.org), 2712–2718.Google Scholar
• NHS (2024) Martha’s Rule. National Health Service. Accessed January 1, 2026, https://www.england.nhs.uk/patient-safety/marthas-rule/.Google Scholar
• NIH (2020) SEER Cancer Statistics Review (CSR) 1975–2017. https://seer.cancer.gov/archive/csr/1975_2017/results_merged/sect_04_breast.pdf.Google Scholar
• Nitta vs HMSA (2024) Case ID: CAAP-24-0000079. Hawaii Medical Association. Accessed January 1, 2026, https://hawaiimedicalassociation.org/page/nitta-hmsa.Google Scholar
• Oberst M, Sontag D (2019) Counterfactual off-policy evaluation with gumbel-max structural causal models. Internat. Conf. Machine Learning (PMLR, New York), 4881–4890.Google Scholar
• Pearl J (2009) Causality, 2nd ed. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK).Crossref, Google Scholar
• Rabin RC (2023) When should women get regular mammograms? At 40, U.S. panel now says. New York Times (May 9), https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/09/health/breast-cancer-mammograms.html.Google Scholar
• Robins JM (1994) Correcting for non-compliance in randomized trials using structural nested mean models. Comm. Statist. Theory Methods 23(8):2379–2412.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Sahinidis NV (2023) BARON 2023.1.5: Global Optimization of Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Programs, User’s Manual.Google Scholar
• Shapiro A, Dentcheva D, Ruszczynski A (2021) Lectures on Stochastic Programming: Modeling and Theory (SIAM, Philadelphia).Crossref, Google Scholar
• Sonnenberg FA, Beck JR (1993) Markov models in medical decision making: A practical guide. Medical Decision Making 13(4):322–338.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Stockton A (2024) ‘What’s my life worth?’ The big business of denying medical care. New York Times (March 14), https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/14/opinion/health-insurance-prior-authorization.html.Google Scholar
• Tawarmalani M, Sahinidis NV (2005) A polyhedral branch-and-cut approach to global optimization. Math. Program. 103(2):225–249.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Tian J, Pearl J (2000) Probabilities of causation: Bounds and identification. Ann. Math. Artificial Intelligence 28(1):287–313.Crossref, Google Scholar
• Tsirtsis S, De A, Rodriguez M (2021) Counterfactual explanations in sequential decision making under uncertainty. Ranzato M, Beygelzimer A, Dauphin Y, Liang P, Vaughan JW, eds. Adv. Neural Inform. Processing Systems, vol. 34 (Curran Associates, Inc., Red Hook, NY), 30127–30139.Google Scholar
• UWBCS (2013) University of Wisconsin breast cancer simulation model. Accessed January 1, 2026, https://resources.cisnet.cancer.gov/registry/packages/uwbcs-wisconsin/.Google Scholar
• Zhang J, Tian J, Bareinboim E (2022) Partial counterfactual identification from observational and experimental data. Internat. Conf. Machine Learn. (PMLR, New York), 26548–26558.Google Scholar
• Zhang J, Denton BT, Balasubramanian H, Shah ND, Inman BA (2012) Optimization of prostate biopsy referral decisions. Manufacturing Service Oper. Management 14(4):529–547.Link, Google Scholar